South African court keeps block on new coal power plants
A court has again put people's right to clean, healthy air ahead of new coal power.
November 14, 2026
A group of environmental organizations has won another round in its fight against new coal power in South African courts. The Supreme Court of Appeal threw out the government's challenge to an earlier High Court ruling that blocked 1,500 megawatts of planned coal-fired generation.
Energy security should not come at the expense of people’s lives, health and well-being.
The coalition, represented by the Centre for Environmental Rights, built its #CancelCoal case around children's constitutional right to a healthy environment. Pollution from coal plants already causes more than 2,200 deaths among South Africans every year, along with many cases of asthma and bronchitis, the group says.
The Minister of Electricity and Energy had argued the extra coal was needed for energy security. But the High Court found that claims about grid stability did not justify trampling on constitutional rights, and that ruling now stands.
Michelle Sithole, a senior associate at the Centre, said the decision doesn't permanently rule out new coal, but it raises the bar the government must clear to pick it. The minister could still take the case to the Constitutional Court. For now, the groups hope electricity planning will put people's health first.